How difficult is MRCP compared to USMLE?
- Crack Medicine
- Sep 15
- 4 min read
TL;DR
The MRCP and USMLE serve different purposes: MRCP is for postgraduate UK training, while USMLE is for entering US residency. If you’re asking how difficult is MRCP compared to USMLE, MRCP tests clinical reasoning breadth across internal medicine, while USMLE is longer, staged, and integrates basic sciences with clinical problem-solving. Both are challenging, but your career goal should guide the choice more than perceived difficulty.
Why this matters
Medical graduates often weigh up MRCP and USMLE as parallel pathways for advancing their careers. Both are rigorous, high-stakes exams, but their structures, recognition, and difficulty profiles differ significantly. A clear understanding helps you choose the exam that aligns with your goals, whether that is specialist training in the UK or residency in the US.
MRCP vs USMLE: Overview
MRCP (Membership of the Royal Colleges of Physicians) is a postgraduate diploma required for entry into higher specialty training in the UK.
USMLE (United States Medical Licensing Examination) is a three-step licensing exam for practice and residency in the US.
Both assess clinical knowledge, but their scope and format vary. MRCP is considered more focused on internal medicine; USMLE is broader, spanning basic sciences to applied clinical reasoning.
Eligibility
MRCP: Candidates must hold a primary medical qualification recognised by the GMC. Attempt usually occurs after 12–24 months of clinical work.
USMLE: Open to international medical graduates (IMGs) as long as their school is listed in the World Directory of Medical Schools. Typically attempted during or immediately after medical school.
Key takeaway: MRCP assumes some postgraduate experience, whereas USMLE is often taken by final-year students or fresh graduates.
Structure and format
Here’s a compact comparison:
Feature | MRCP | USMLE |
Parts/Steps | 3 (Part 1, Part 2 Written, PACES) | 3 (Step 1, Step 2 CK, Step 3) |
Focus | Internal medicine & clinical reasoning | Basic science + clinical integration |
Exam style | MCQs & clinical stations | MCQs & clinical case simulations |
Duration | 3–4 years typical completion | 2–4 years typical completion |
MRCP Part 1: 2 papers, 100 MCQs each, testing breadth of clinical medicine.
USMLE Step 1: One-day test, heavily basic science.
USMLE Step 2 CK: Clinical knowledge.
USMLE Step 3: Clinical management and case simulations.
Cost and time commitment
MRCP: Part 1 costs ~£460 internationally (varies by centre)【MRCP official】. Most candidates take 2–3 attempts across all parts.
USMLE: Each Step costs ~$1,000–$1,200, plus travel to test centres. IMG candidates spend significantly on electives, ECFMG certification, and applications.
Time:
MRCP prep averages 6–12 months per part.
USMLE prep often 1–2 years total, especially for IMGs balancing electives and observerships.
Recognition and career pathways
MRCP: Recognised in the UK, GCC, Singapore, Hong Kong, and several Commonwealth countries. It directly enables progression to UK higher specialty training.
USMLE: Required for residency and practice in the US. Recognition outside the US is limited, though some programmes abroad respect it as a benchmark of rigour.
Summary: Choose MRCP if you want a UK/NHS career; USMLE if you aim for the US.
Difficulty comparison
The core question — how difficult is MRCP compared to USMLE?
MRCP: Tests recall and application across all specialties of internal medicine. Candidates often struggle with the breadth and clinical detail.
USMLE: Step 1 is notoriously conceptual and basic-science heavy; Step 2 CK requires integrated clinical reasoning; Step 3 adds management scenarios.
Both require strong test-taking skills. Many clinicians feel USMLE Step 1 is harder for graduates further removed from basic sciences, while MRCP is harder for those with less hands-on clinical exposure.
Who each exam suits
MRCP → Doctors aiming for NHS specialty training or recognition in Commonwealth/Gulf countries.
USMLE → Graduates targeting US residency and practice.
Hybrid option → Some candidates attempt both, but this is resource-intensive.
Practical examples / mini-cases
Example 1: A UK foundation doctor wanting cardiology training would choose MRCP Part 1 within 18 months of graduation.
Example 2: An IMG medical student in India planning to match into US internal medicine would prioritise USMLE Step 1 early.
Example 3: A Gulf-based physician aiming for career mobility in both regions may attempt MRCP first, then USMLE, but must plan finances and time carefully.
Common pitfalls
Failing to align exam choice with long-term career goals.
Underestimating MRCP’s breadth across all internal medicine specialties.
Treating USMLE as purely academic and neglecting clinical exposure.
Poor resource planning — both exams involve high costs.
Attempting both exams simultaneously without realistic scheduling.
FAQs
1. Is MRCP easier than USMLE?
Not necessarily. MRCP is more clinical and broad, USMLE Step 1 is more conceptual. Difficulty depends on your training stage.
2. Can MRCP replace USMLE for US practice?
No. USMLE is mandatory for licensing in the US. MRCP has no substitute role there.
3. Which exam is faster to complete?
MRCP can be completed in 2–3 years; USMLE usually takes longer due to residency application timelines.
4. Do I need MRCP to work in the UK?
For specialty training, yes. GMC registration alone permits practice, but MRCP is required for progression.
5. Can I prepare for MRCP Part 1 with free resources?
Yes, but structured practice using QBank tools is essential. Crack Medicine offers Free MRCP MCQs to get started.
Ready to start?
Both MRCP and USMLE are tough, but they open different doors. If you are targeting UK training, start early with MRCP Part 1 overview. Explore Crack Medicine’s Free MRCP MCQs and Start a mock test to benchmark your readiness. For more comparisons and strategies, browse our full blog hub.
Sources
MRCP(UK) Official Site
USMLE Official Site
GMC Guidance
Comments